Cyclopropylcarbinyl-to-homoallyl carbocation equilibria influence the stereospecificity in the nucleophilic substitution of cyclopropylcarbinols

The synthesis of quaternary homoallylic halides and trichloroacetates from cyclopropylcarbinols, as reported by Marek in 2020 (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2020, 142, 5543-5548), is one of the few reported examples of stereospecific nucleophilic substitution involving chiral bridged carbocations. However, for the phenyl-substituted substrates the stereoselectivity of the reaction is poor and a mixture of diastereomers is obtained. In order to understand the nature of the intermediates involved in this transformation and explain the loss of selectivity for certain substrates, we have performed a Density Functional Theory investigation of the reaction mechanism at the DLPNO-CCSD(T)/Def2TZVPP level of theory. Our results indicate that cyclopropylcarbinyl cations are stable intermediates in this reaction, while bicyclobutonium structures are high-energy transition structures and as such are not involved, regardless of the substitution pattern on the substrate. Instead, multiple rearrangement pathways of cyclopropylcarbinyl cations have been located, including rotations around their π-bonds and ring openings to homoallylic cations. Importantly, the relative energies of these homoallylic cations and of the activation barriers to reach them are correlated to the nature of the substituents. While direct nucleophilic attack on the chiral cyclopropylcarbinyl cation is kinetically favored for most systems, the rearrangements become competitive with nucleophilic attack for the phenyl-substituted systems, leading to a loss of selectivity through a mixture of rearranged carbocation intermediates. As such, it appears that stereospecific reactions of chiral cyclopropylcarbinyl cations depend on the ability of these cations to access homoallylic structures, from which selectivity is not guaranteed.